SBEC votes to water down superintendent certification standards, looks to baseball and business for guidance

SBECIf you visit the website of the Texas Education Agency (TEA) and look up its description of the State Board for Educator Certification (SBEC), you’ll read that SBEC “was created by the Texas Legislature in 1995 to recognize public school educators as professionals and grant educators the authority to govern the standards of their profession.” For multiple legislative sessions, SBEC has been threatened with the possibility of being disbanded by the legislature through the sunset review process. Again and again, educator groups have come to the defense of SBEC, defending educators’ rights to set the standards for their own profession through a board that is made up primarily of educators. That’s why it’s disappointing when SBEC takes actions that are so clearly inspired by outside business interests and those with no education experience whatsoever. Today, unfortunately, was one of those days, as SBEC took a step that will make it easier for individuals with no education experience to take on important leadership roles in public education.

SBEC is holding its regular meeting today, Aug. 7. Shortly before lunch, the board voted to give preliminary approval to a rule change that would allow someone to become a school superintendent despite having neither experience as a classroom teacher and principal nor managerial experience. The change was apparently instigated by one of two stakeholder groups that TEA convened late last year to recommend revisions to 19 TAC Chapter 242, Superintendent Certificate, Rule §242.20 on “Requirements for the Issuance of the Standard Superintendent Certificate,” and Rule §242.25 on “Requirements for the First-Time Superintendent in Texas.” One stakeholder group was believed to be composed primarily of business leaders, which favored allowing non-educators to fill superintendent vacancies. An additional stakeholder group made up of administrators and school board trustees also made a recommendation to the board, but their recommendation only allowed for non-principals who have three years of specific managerial experience within a school district to seek superintendent certification. That latter recommendation was also included as a separate pathway to superintendent certification. Neither pathway, however, would require any teaching experience.

ATPE Lobbyist Kate Kuhlmann

Kate Kuhlmann

At today’s meeting, ATPE Lobbyist Kate Kuhlmann testified that successful superintendents need both teaching and managerial experience. “Every superintendent needs a strong understanding of how education works, the needs of every student, and how administrative influence can change educational outcomes,” Kuhlmann told the board. “This is something that can only be gained from first-hand experience in the classroom.” Sharing input from an ATPE member who serves as an assistant superintendent, Kuhlmann outlined the types of daily decisions made by superintendents that require both managerial experience and the “perspective of classroom teaching.” ATPE was the only educator group to testify against the proposed rule change for new superintendents today.

The most outspoken advocate on the board for the rule change to allow “non-traditional” superintendents to be hired without need for a waiver was public SBEC member Laurie Bricker of Houston. Bricker expressed her belief that school boards should have authority to hire someone like Michael Dell or Bill Gates to serve as a their superintendents. She authored a last-minute substitute motion, ultimately accepted by the board, that removed language that would have required a school board of trustees to post publicly its reasons for hiring any such “non-traditional” superintendent under the new rules being proposed today. Dr. Rex Peebles, Assistant Commissioner for the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board, who serves as a non-voting member of SBEC, spoke against that change, arguing that transparency to the community and especially to faculty members working within the school district should be required. Bricker rejected a suggestion by SBEC member Suzanne McCall, a teacher, to add a requirement for TEA to approve the hire of any “non-traditional” superintendent, which McCall viewed as an extra layer of oversight and protection. Bricker was adamant that elected school board trustees alone should have blanket authority for hiring superintendents. Another public member who serves on the SBEC board, Leon Leal, compared the proposal to Major League Baseball, arguing that professional baseball teams have been very successful after being given authority to hire managers who were not former players.

In the end, SBEC members McCall and Kathryn Everest, a school counselor, were the only ones to vote against the motion to water down the superintendent certification rules. Next, the proposed rule change will be published for public comments and SBEC will have another opportunity to approve it on second and final reading at its next meeting. Stay tuned to Teach the Vote for updates.

In more positive news, the board approved allowing at least one classroom teacher and one counselor to serve on its Educator Preparation Advisory Committee (EPAC). The request to add teacher representatives to the existing committee was made by ATPE’s Kate Kuhlmann in testimony today. The committee, made primarily of representatives of educator preparation programs (EPPs), meets quarterly to provide input on issues relating to EPPs. The EPAC has existed since 2006, and SBEC only recently voted to add some school district representatives to the committee. Today’s action in response to ATPE’s request will ensure that classroom teachers can also participate in discussions about preparing future educators and the need for any regulatory changes.

Today’s SBEC agenda also included discussions of future changes to certification exams and rules pertaining to admission to an educator preparation program. Some of those changes were necessitated by legislation passed earlier this year. How the board handles disciplinary cases involving educators was an additional topic of discussion today.

Share Button

11 thoughts on “SBEC votes to water down superintendent certification standards, looks to baseball and business for guidance

  1. Jayne Serna

    Thanks, Kate, for standing up for the children of Texas! Thanks also to SBEC members McCall and Everest. Will look for the public comment period.

    1. Rae Rowe

      Thank you Kate. I am proud to be a member of ATPE. Keep up the good work. There has been enough watering down of education on all levels. The SBEC needs to respect our profession.

  2. Danny

    You know what this means, right? Boards will now be able to hire their friends who has “managed” their farm and ranch operation or a gas station. They may have had teaching experience long ago, but no principal experience. This is a huge blow to the professional status of administrators, who have worked long hours and have trained extensively to reach a high level of professionalism. So, we are going to turn over the leadership of our schools to failed teachers who have owned a gas station (no offense intended to gas station owners…just used as an example). Why don’t we just start letting anyone be a doctor, there is a shortage of them, right? SBEC needs to use some common sense here instead of bowing to special interests.

  3. Angela

    Maybe, just maybe, they are thinking outside the box. Our current administrators are doing such a wonderful job. Kids are graduating without knowledge of the real world. They have no idea how to budget, manage their bank account, work in the real world, get a job to pay for college instead of rack up debt that they cannot pay, etc. They just know how to use a credit card with no idea of how this will affect them in the future. Kids have learned how to take a test and follow instructions. There is no outside thinking, no encouragement to think, other than take the test. So explain to me, why this is such a bad idea to give others an opportunity to show that they may be better than the standard take the test administrators.

  4. Pingback: Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: Aug. 14, 2015 | Teach the Vote

  5. Pingback: Damage control??--- Missouri City Leadership Luncheon series to feature HCC Chancellor, Fort Bend ISD Superintendent

  6. Pingback: Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: Sept. 4, 2015 | Teach the Vote

  7. Pingback: ATPE opposes controversial change to superintendent certification rule; submits formal input to SBEC | Teach the Vote

  8. Pingback: SBEC votes to approve changes to superintendent certification criteria | Teach the Vote

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *